142764 Members
23 Forums
229376 Topics
2170150 Posts
Max Online: 3009 @ 12/15/09 04:15 PM
|
|
|
#2296580 - 11/06/09 05:42 PM
The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
|
anti-heroic protagonist
Registered: 04/30/09
Posts: 8575
Loc: N. America (Seattle & Van)
|
Cosmetic neurology, more generally cosmetic pharmacology, has to do with taking drugs to improve cognitive function, movements, moods, and general mental functioning in healthy normal individuals.
I have selected a few key passages from the following 2008 article in an academic journal. I would appreciate your views.
"When the boss turns pusher: a proposal for employee protections in the age of cosmetic neurology" by JM Appel (J Med Ethics 2008;34:616–618)
Chatterjee argued that Western medicine stands on the brink of an inevitable neuropharmacological revolution in which healthy people will be ‘‘treated’’ with brain-enhancing drugs in order to improve performance in such fields as attention, learning and memory.
Chatterjee has documented dozens of different ways in which therapeutic agents may also be harnessed to augment the mental abilities of individuals without illnesses— ranging from commercial airplane pilots whose performance in simulated emergencies improved when trained on a reversible acetylcholinesterase inhibitor, donepezil, to the use of selective serotonin reuptake inhibitors in order to foster ‘‘affiliative behaviour’’ in healthy, non-depressed adults.
Transhumanist philosophers, such as Nick Bostrom and Max More, have long sought in medical technology an opportunity to overcome ‘‘traditional human limitations’’ for the benefit of society. Libertarian bioethicists argue for access to these advances on autonomy grounds, demanding that individuals be permitted to use any available technology for self-improvement.9 Anita Silvers, the prominent San Francisco State Universitybased bioethicist and disability-rights advocate, writes that such modifications are a basic human right and the very ‘‘essence of freedom’’. Military physicians, citing the dangers of sleep-restricted environments, claim an entitlement—and even a moral duty—to ‘‘help healthy inviduals optimise their cognitive potential’’.
In contrast, conservative critics of neurocognitive enhancement, such as Francis Fukuyama, see unchecked tinkering with the healthy brain as an unnatural threat to the ‘‘human essence’’; Fukuyama fears that such cosmetic interventions could ultimately lead to an entrenched inegalitarianism that would undermine democratic institutions. In addition, University of Rochester philosopher Richard Dees objects to Chatterjee’s claim that a neurocognitive revolution is an inevitable result of military pressures and market forces. Dees views this outlook as the surrender of ethics to power—an abnegation of moral duty—and he calls for the use of ‘‘democratic checks’’ in order to ‘‘collectively control our own destinies’’ in the face of the neurocosmetic onslaught.
_________________________
What separates us all from one another is simply society itself, or...politics. Truest society...is a wider, deeper society...revealed by our common anxieties, our desires, our secret nostalgias...It is the human condition that directs the social condition, not vice versa. Eugène Ionesco Avy? A gift from "gods"!
KimKardashian--BritneySpears--ChelsieHightower BlakeLively--Jennifer L Hewitt--ElizaDushku EvaLongoria--CatherineBell MeganFox--JenniferLopez
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#2296953 - 11/06/09 08:58 PM
Re: The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
[Re: Juicy_Juicy]
|
The Witness
Registered: 12/28/04
Posts: 7576
Loc: In a country with no army =)
|
Sounds a lot like Bioshock to me, at least at first glance.
_________________________
Crushingly Beautiful (tm) Ladies - 2009
Summer Glau --*-- Olivia Wilde --*-- Rachel McAdams --*-- Mila Kunis
Bar Refaeli --*-- Kelly Brook --*-- Doutzen Kroes --*-- Olga Kurylenko
Leighton Meester --*-- Rachel Bilson --*-- Julie Ordon --*-- Nozomi Sasaki
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#2296964 - 11/06/09 09:06 PM
Re: The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
[Re: WesMordine]
|
anti-heroic protagonist
Registered: 04/30/09
Posts: 8575
Loc: N. America (Seattle & Van)
|
Huh?
_________________________
What separates us all from one another is simply society itself, or...politics. Truest society...is a wider, deeper society...revealed by our common anxieties, our desires, our secret nostalgias...It is the human condition that directs the social condition, not vice versa. Eugène Ionesco Avy? A gift from "gods"!
KimKardashian--BritneySpears--ChelsieHightower BlakeLively--Jennifer L Hewitt--ElizaDushku EvaLongoria--CatherineBell MeganFox--JenniferLopez
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#2296981 - 11/06/09 09:14 PM
Re: The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
[Re: Juicy_Juicy]
|
The Witness
Registered: 12/28/04
Posts: 7576
Loc: In a country with no army =)
|
Not a gamer yourself, eh? Nobody's perfect. Bioshock is 2007's Game of the Year. Here, look it up. http://www.metacritic.com/games/platforms/pc/bioshock?q=Bioshock
_________________________
Crushingly Beautiful (tm) Ladies - 2009
Summer Glau --*-- Olivia Wilde --*-- Rachel McAdams --*-- Mila Kunis
Bar Refaeli --*-- Kelly Brook --*-- Doutzen Kroes --*-- Olga Kurylenko
Leighton Meester --*-- Rachel Bilson --*-- Julie Ordon --*-- Nozomi Sasaki
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#2297313 - 11/07/09 03:44 AM
Re: The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
[Re: WesMordine]
|
anti-heroic protagonist
Registered: 04/30/09
Posts: 8575
Loc: N. America (Seattle & Van)
|
Got ya. Yeah, something like that but less fun. 
_________________________
What separates us all from one another is simply society itself, or...politics. Truest society...is a wider, deeper society...revealed by our common anxieties, our desires, our secret nostalgias...It is the human condition that directs the social condition, not vice versa. Eugène Ionesco Avy? A gift from "gods"!
KimKardashian--BritneySpears--ChelsieHightower BlakeLively--Jennifer L Hewitt--ElizaDushku EvaLongoria--CatherineBell MeganFox--JenniferLopez
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
#2297398 - 11/07/09 06:31 AM
Re: The Ethics of Cosmetic Neurology
[Re: Juicy_Juicy]
|
Established Member
Registered: 07/31/04
Posts: 621
Loc: California
|
Well I am not so sure this will ever become a front-burner issue in ethics because most people don't have the interest level or discipline to do brain optimization.
We have known for years that there are herbs and supplements that enhance cognitive function, as well as mind exercises (puzzles, counting exercises, etc.) recommended by neuroscientists to sharpen the mind. But I am willing to bet that you can only count on one hand the number of people you personally know who pursue these enhancements on a daily basis.
Most people are striving to just get through their day and can't even get to the point of adequate sleep, much less neural optimization. You might think that everyone wants to be like Raymond Kurzweil, but few actually ever even try.
|
|
Top
|
|
|
|
|
|